Seneca Nation Rejoices as CAMA Deals Denial to
Dangerous Wastewater Treatment Facility on Allegheny River
ALLEGANY TERRITORY, SALAMANCA, N.Y. – In a special meeting that lasted approximately 25 minutes, the Coudersport Area Municipal Authority (CAMA) dealt the latest in a series of blows to a controversial proposed wastewater treatment facility near the headwaters of the Allegheny River last night.
The Seneca Nation applauded the votes by the CAMA board to terminate all permits for the project, which is being proposed by Epiphany Allegheny LLC (Epiphany). The CAMA board also voted to immediately terminate CAMA’s lease relationship with Epiphany, and to authorize the submission of the permits withdrawal to the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection (PA DEP).
“Last night, the CAMA board showed great courage and leadership in placing the greater good of the people and the environment above all else,” said Seneca Nation President Todd Gates. “For the past several weeks, the Seneca Nation has been working to communicate a simple message: not here, not on our river. Don’t mortgage our future on some sort of test project. The Seneca Nation is grateful to CAMA for hearing our voices, heeding our message and welcoming our input before making their decision.”
The CAMA vote comes days after the announcement by JKLM Energy that it would no longer pursue treatment at the proposed plant, and weeks after the Coudersport Borough Council voted 5-1 opposing the project.
“The river, Ohi:yo’, will live longer than any of us. CAMA has helped to ensure a long, healthy life for the river and for the lives it will help to sustain. Their decision is a great victory for today, and for generations to come,” President Gates said. “I want to thank our many neighbors from Pennsylvania and New York who voiced their concerns and share our position. We will forever defend the Ohi:yo’.”
From the Offices of Public Herald, Nonprofit Investigative News
Dear Friends of the Seneca Nation,
It has come to our attention that “treated” radioactive shale gas waste is proposed for discharge into the Ohi:yo’ (beautiful river in our language), more commonly known as the Allegany (also spelled Allegheny) River in Pennsylvania upstream from the Seneca Nation. Critical concerns first publicized by investigative journalists at Public Herald cite recent studies by scientists at Duke University, Duquesne University, and Penn State University that found an accumulation of radiation in river sediment near existing oil and gas wastewater treatment facilities in Pennsylvania.
Pittsburgh-based Epiphany Allegheny, LLC claims to have “new technology” that turns shale gas wastewater into “pure, clean water,” according to their August 2017 permit application to the Pennsylvania Dept. of Environmental Protection (PA DEP). However, this technology has not been thoroughly tested, and Epiphany does not plan to monitor key contaminants of concern, including radioisotopes, before discharging 42,000 gallons of treated waste into the Allegany River per day, with a potential daily maximum of 80,000 gallons.
Radioactive material in shale gas fracking waste will not be
completely eliminated by treatment:
“Naturally-occurring radioactive material (NORM) and salts can be removed from the wastewater to background levels. However, even if only a small amount of radium would remain in the outfall, and the volume of effluents is large, one can expect to see build up of NORM in the impacted sediments.”
– Dr. Avner Vengosh, February 1, 2018
Our concerns are now echoed by the U.S. Army Corp of Engineers, U.S. Department of the Interior, Pennsylvania Fish & Boat Commission, New York State Department of Environmental Conservation, and several independent scientists in official comments submitted to PA DEP.
The Seneca Nation requested that PA DEP hold a public hearing on the nation’s territory downstream from the proposed facility. However, PA DEP denied that request. Since the state will not require continuous water quality testing and reporting for radioactive material in the influent and effluent we urge you to request PA DEP and U.S. EPA deny the Epiphany Allegheny, LLC permit application.
Seneca Nation of Indians Council
Allegany: Tina Abrams, Ricky Armstrong, Jr., Arlene Bova, William Canella, Al George, Stephen Gordon, Timothy Waterman, Mike Williams
Cattaraugus: Linda Doxtator, Jeff Gill, Rick Jemison, Ross John Sr., Llona LeRoy, Presley Redeye, Keith White Sr., John Williams Jr.
Melissa A. Troutman, Executive Director, Public Herald, (724) 388-0464
Joshua B. Pribanic, Editor-in-Chief, Public Herald, (419) 202-8503
From the Offices of Public Herald, Nonprofit Investigative News
CHART OF PROPOSED EPIPHANY ALLEGHENY, LLC
UPPER ALLEGANY WATERSHED
DANGERS OF EPIPHANY ALLEGHENY WASTE WATER PLANT
CONCERNS FROM OTHER AGENCIES:
The Department of Army, Corp of Engineers:
● The proposed facility will be located in a 100-year floodplain. Waste and chemicals stored onsite pose high risk to river ecosystem in the likely event of a flood.
● More thorough waste characterization and continuous water quality monitoring of distillate and discharge for contaminants of concern, including radioisotopes, benzene, barium, bromide, etc.
Department of the Interior, Fish & Wildlife:
● The federally endangered rayed bean mussel has been observed just downstream of the proposed discharge facility. Recent studies demonstrate mussels experience toxicity at concentrations below State and Federal standards for contaminants.
Pennsylvania Fish & Boat Commission:
● Several endangered and protected aquatic species live in the Allegheny River at the site of the proposed facility.
New York Department of Environmental Conservation:
● The discharge permit for this facility does not include monitoring of effluent limits of parameters of concern and recommends inclusion of continuous influent and effluent sampling.
OTHER IMPORTANT FACTS:
● There are no federal or state regulations being applied for daily testing of influent or effluent for radioactive elements. Therefore, the burden of proof rests on those directly impacted.
● Fracking includes a host of carcinogenic volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and semi-volatile organic compounds (SVOCs). Daily testing for these compounds is also not required by state or federal agencies for the proposed facility.
● The company, Epiphany Allegheny LLC, claims that its treatment process will produce “pure, clean water.” This claim is false by definition and attempts to mislead the public.
● The Allegheny watershed is part of the Triple Divide, a precious ecosystem that gives birth to three major U.S. rivers (Ohio, Susquehanna, and Genesee) which serve water to millions of people downstream in addition to the Seneca Nation, from Lake Ontario to the Chesapeake Bay to the Gulf of Mexico. The accumulation of radioactive materials in these headwaters are a national issue.
● The recently released Triple Divide [Redacted] documentary about the Triple Divide and risks of water contamination related to fracking in Pennsylvania is available from Public Herald.
"Allowing this plan to move forward would permit poisonous contaminants to travel downstream into New York State and onto the sovereign ancestral lands of the Seneca Nation, which sit upon the Ohi:yo' (Allegany River), the Seneca people have a deep spiritual connection with the land and we depend on our natural resources, including native plants, trees, wildlife, fish and water. These resources are critical components of our culture. We will zealously defend and protect what remains of our territories and our natural resources, which would be further threatened by this dangerous plan."